What are my treatment options?
Treatment options overview
Treatment options include mastectomy or breast
conservation therapy (BCT). Mastectomy is an operation to remove the entire
breast, including the nipple and glands under the arms called axillary nodes. Mastectomy usually requires a hospital stay. Women who undergo a
mastectomy have the option of breast reconstruction.
Breast conservation surgery removes the breast tumor
and a margin of surrounding normal tissues. It is also known by other names: lumpectomy, partial mastectomy, segmental mastectomy and quadrantectomy. Radiation therapy follows lumpectomy to eliminate any microscopic cancer cells in the
remaining breast tissue. The purpose of breast conservation therapy is to give
women the same cure rate they would have if they were treated with a mastectomy
but to leave the breast intact, with an appearance and texture as close as
possible to what they had before treatment. The surgeon may remove the lymph
nodes at the same time as the lumpectomy procedure or later. It is estimated
that 75 percent to 80 percent of patients can be treated with breast conservation
therapy rather than mastectomy with excellent results. Years of clinical study
have proven that breast conservation therapy offers the same cure rate as
mastectomy.
Your radiation therapy procedure might include:
External Beam Therapy - see
External Beam Therapy page
Intensity-Modulated Radiation Therapy - see
Intensity-Modulated Radiation Therapy page
Interstitial Therapy (or "Brachytherapy")
- the temporary placement of radioactive materials within the breast,
usually employed to give an extra dose of radiation to the area of the
excision site (called a "boost"). - see
Brachytherapy page
Patients may also have chemotherapy or hormonal therapy if there is a risk that the cancer may have spread outside
of the breast to other body organs.
How can I make a decision between mastectomy and
breast conservation therapy?
Breast conservation therapy is used for patients with
early-stage invasive breast cancers (called Stage I and Stage II in the
classification system). It is also used for patients with ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS, called Stage 0). Some of the reasons to not have
breast conservation therapy include: personal preference; increased risk of
complications from radiation therapy in individuals with certain rare medical
conditions; and tumors that are more likely than average to have a relapse in a
breast with breast conservation therapy.
Most patients can choose a treatment based on other
factors, such as convenience (for example, how far you must travel to receive
radiation therapy) or personal preference (feeling safer if you undergo a
mastectomy or being very worried about the possible side effects from radiation
therapy). Most women prefer to keep their breast if this is possible to do
safely, but there is no right answer for everyone. However, this decision is not
one the physician can make for you.
Nearly all physicians will recommend patients be treated
with mastectomy instead of breast conservation therapy when the risk of
recurrence in the breast is more than 20 percent. This is the case for
only a small number of women, however.
Is radiation therapy necessary if the margins of the
removed tissue are negative?
Many studies have reviewed this approach for patients
with invasive cancers. Nearly all show that the risk of relapse in the breast is much
higher when radiation is not used (20 percent to 40 percent) than when it is (5 percent
to 10 percent). Having breast cancer reappear in this way is a very traumatic
event psychologically. Also, patients may need to have a mastectomy to be cured
in this situation, so in more cases they may lose the breast than if they had
undergone radiation therapy initially. Finally, not everyone who has a
recurrence in the breast can be cured. Therefore, radiation therapy after
lumpectomy is the standard treatment around the world.
There are several recent studies in which older patients with small, favorable invasive cancers have had a low risk of local relapse when treated with lumpectomy and hormonal therapy without radiation therapy. There is still uncertainty about the long-term results with this approach or about which individuals will do best without radiation therapy. This issue should be discussed in detail with your doctor.
For patients with noninvasive cancer (known as "ductal
carcinoma in situ") matters are more complicated. Lumpectomy without
radiation works well for many patients. However, there is disagreement on who
can be treated safely with just a lumpectomy. This should be discussed in detail
with your doctor.
What are the cosmetic results of breast conservation
therapy?
Eighty percent to 90 percent of women treated with modern surgery and radiotherapy
techniques have excellent or good cosmetic results; that is, little or
no change in the treated breast in size, shape, texture or appearance
compared with what it was like before treatment.
Patients with large breasts seem to have greater
shrinkage of the breast after radiation therapy than do smaller-breasted
patients. However, this problem usually can be overcome with the use of higher
x-ray energies.
What is the prognosis after recurrence?
Many patients with a recurrence of breast cancer can
be successfully treated, often with methods other than radiation if radiation
was used in the initial treatment. For patients treated initially for invasive
breast cancer, 5 percent to 10 percent will be found to have distant metastases at the time of discovery of the breast recurrence. The same proportion will have
recurrences that are too extensive to be operated on. These patients are rarely,
if ever, cured. Five-year cure rates for patients with relapse after breast
conservation therapy are approximately 60 percent to 75 percent if the relapse is
confined to the breast and a mastectomy is then performed.
For patients treated initially for ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS), about one-half of recurrences are invasive and
one-half noninvasive DCIS. Cure rates following recurrence after initial breast
conservation therapy have been high (90 percent to 100 percent) in some studies but are
not always perfect.
What are possible side effects of radiation therapy?
There are no immediate side effects from each
radiation treatment given to the breast. Patients do not develop nausea or hair
loss on the head.
Most patients develop mild fatigue that builds up
gradually over the course of therapy. This slowly goes away one to two
months following the radiation therapy. Most patients develop dull aches or sharp
shooting pains in the breast that may last for a few seconds or minutes. It is
rare for patients to need any medication for this. The most common side effect
needing attention is skin reaction. Most patients develop reddening, dryness and
itching of the skin after a few weeks. Some patients develop substantial
irritation.
Skin care recommendations include:
- Keeping the skin clean and dry using warm water
and gentle soap
- Avoiding extreme temperatures while bathing
- Avoiding trauma to the skin and sun exposure (use
a sunscreen with at least SPF 15)
- Avoiding shaving the treatment area with
a razor blade (use an electric razor if necessary)
- Avoiding use of perfumes, cosmetics, after-shave
or deodorants in the treatment area (use cornstarch with or without
baking soda in place of deodorants)
- Using only recommended unscented creams or lotions
after daily treatment.
Some patients develop a sunburn-like reaction with
blistering and peeling of the skin, called "moist desquamation." This
usually occurs in the fold under the breast or in the fold between the breast
and the arm, or sometimes in the area given a radiation boost. Most people with
a limited area of moist desquamation can continue treatment without
interruption. When treatment must be interrupted, the skin usually heals enough
to allow radiation to be resumed in five to seven days. Skin reactions usually
heal completely within a few weeks of completing radiotherapy.